Why can't you make up for the white matter? ——The collision of traditional customs and modern concepts
Recently, the discussion about "making up gifts for nothing" has sparked heated discussions on social media. Many young people are confused by the "no make-up gift" rule in traditional funeral rituals, and even think it is an inhumane and bad habit. This article will combine hot topic data from the entire Internet in the past 10 days to analyze the deep logic of this custom from a cultural, psychological and social perspective.
| hot topics | Number of discussions (10,000) | Main points of dispute |
|---|---|---|
| The extra gift was rejected | 28.5 | Should we keep pace with the times? |
| Reform of funeral customs | 19.2 | The conflict between tradition and reality |
| Young people don’t understand etiquette | 15.7 | generational cognitive differences |
| Difficulties of traveling to other places for funerals | 12.3 | Impact of modern lifestyle |
1. The cultural roots of traditional customs
1.time irreversibility: The ancients believed that funerals have the characteristic of "no waiting when the time comes", and the "Book of Rites" clearly records "no time for funerals", expressing absolute respect for the deceased.
2.ritual integrity: The traditional funeral ceremony includes the complete process of "initial mourning - condolences - funeral - burial". Complementary gifts will destroy the sanctity of the ceremony.
3.The concept of yin and yang: Folk belief believes that the deceased went to the underworld immediately after the "March 7", and the make-up gift cannot be conveyed to the other side.
| area | Taboo days | special regulations |
|---|---|---|
| North China | Within 49 days | It can be replaced by sacrifices but not by gift money. |
| Jiangsu and Zhejiang | Within 35 days | Paper money for replenishing incense candles is allowed |
| Lingnan | Within a hundred days | Can replenish "merit gold" |
2. Realistic contradictions in modern society
1.Increased population mobility: According to statistics in 2023, my country's floating population will reach 376 million, and many people will not be able to attend funerals in time.
2.new expression: New forms such as online condolences and cloud sacrifices conflict with traditional rules.
3.economic factors: Some families regard top-up gifts as an important source of income, which is contrary to the "simplification of funerals" policy.
3. Compromise plan suggested by experts
1.emotion substitution principle: You can make up for it by accompanying you afterwards and assisting in handling funeral affairs.
2.symbolic compensation: Express your feelings at anniversary festivals, Qingming Festival, etc.
3.cultural explanation mechanism: The host should clearly inform the host that "it is not a refusal of etiquette but an observance of the ancient rules."
| solution | support rate | Applicable scenarios |
|---|---|---|
| Condolences afterwards | 68% | Colleagues/common friends |
| Charitable donation | 45% | intellectual family |
| Labor assistance | 72% | relatives/close friends |
Conclusion:In a rapidly changing society, traditional customs require more flexible interpretations. Understanding the cultural logic behind "not making up for the gift" is more important than simply criticizing or blindly following. As folklorist Professor Wang Juan said: "The core of etiquette is the heart, and the form should serve the emotion rather than constrain it."
check the details
check the details
en
